top of page

FOR LEADERS WHO RUN PROJECTS, SHUTDOWNS AND CAPITAL WORKS

​

Critical chain and adaptive project management

​

Projects run late for much the same reason plants do: everyone is kept busy, and the few things that set the pace get no protection. This page describes how Stratflow applies critical chain project management, and how we add near real-time feedback from the people doing the work.

WHY PROJECTS SLIP

​

Good people, good plans, late projects

​

Project plans assume reasonably stable conditions. Then the design changes, a contractor falls behind or a critical item arrives late, and the plan starts to drift.

​

Eliyahu Goldratt described the patterns underneath in Critical Chain (1997):

  • Each task estimate carries its own safety margin, and the margin gets used up. Work starts late because there seems to be time, and rarely finishes early even when it could.

  • People spread across several projects switch between them, and every switch lengthens all of them.

  • Bad news travels slowly to the people with the authority to act, so executives are often the last to learn that a project is off track.

​

Goldratt also argued that the ultimate constraint in most organisations is management attention. On a project that attention goes to chasing late tasks, moving people between jobs and re-planning. Critical chain gives much of it back.

THE METHOD

​

Critical chain in plain terms

​

Five changes, made together. The method works alongside whatever project management standard and software the team already uses.

1 Find the critical chain

​

It is the longest path through the project once both task links and shared people or equipment are counted. It sets the finish date.

​

2 Pool the safety

​

Take the hidden margin out of each task and put part of it at the end as one project buffer, with smaller feeding buffers where other paths join the chain.

​

3 Release fewer projects at once

​

Start new work at the pace of the most loaded team. With fewer projects open, each one finishes sooner.

4 Run the project on buffer status

​

One chart compares how much of the chain is complete with how much of the buffer is used. Green, amber and red show which tasks need help today, on a visual board everyone can read.

​

5 Hand work on as soon as it is done

​

Like a relay runner, the next person is ready when the work arrives.

Fewer jobs open, one priority list and early warning from the buffer.

​

That is how critical chain gives management attention back to the work.

WHEN THE PROJECT WILL NOT SIT STILL

​

Adaptive project management

​

On large construction and capital projects most of the work is done by contractors, design is often incomplete when work starts, and the constraint moves as the project moves. A fixed plan cannot keep up, and the information that matters most rarely reaches the formal reports.

HOW IT WORKS NOW

​

Start with the people who see the delays

​

In narrative sessions, frontline managers, supervisors, engineers and contractors describe what is holding their work up.

​

The patterns are mapped as a flow chart with the leverage points marked, so everyone coordinates around the same picture and the few fixes that matter get done first.

THE NEXT STEP

​

From sessions to a continuous feed

​

We are developing the approach further with the Cynefin framework from complexity science and SenseMaker. Short accounts are recorded as the work happens and shown on a map of where work is being held up, and where people are bending the rules to get work done.

​

Leaders read the accounts behind each point, choose where to act, and watch the map shift as the fix takes hold.

A cluster of stories about bending the rules is an early warning that a hazard is being worked around.

CASE: AN $800 MILLION LIGHT RAIL PROJECT, 2018

​

Back on schedule within months

​

A large construction company was running over time and budget on a light rail project, and senior executives were worried by a rising number of near misses.

​

Hendrik ran narrative sessions with frontline managers, supervisors, engineers and contractors, then mapped the patterns as a flow chart with the leverage points marked. That chart gave everyone the same picture to coordinate around. Within a few months the project was back on schedule and costs were under control.

​

Safety improved markedly as well. People who worked on the project, its safety staff among them, still spoke of it years afterwards.

FEWER THINGS IN PROGRESS

​

Where project flow and safety meet

​

We hold, and Hendrik’s peer-reviewed article on the mining fatality plateau argues, that freed management attention is what lets high reliability behaviour take root.

​

Each of the five habits Weick and Sutcliffe describe, from preoccupation with failure to deference to expertise, needs leaders with time to notice and respond. We see freeing that attention as a necessary step towards high reliability, though not a sufficient one, and we report safety results separately from schedule results.

​

For testing whether critical controls work in the field, see the Control Effectiveness Assessment, developed by Kelvin Genn at Art of Work, on the Beyond Green Ticks page.

​

For a project game, the Development game on the Mine Sim page is written for development and project teams and the contractors who work with them. About 45 minutes.

EVIDENCE AND LIMITS

​

Held to what it shows

​

The light rail case is one project. It is not a forecast for any other project.

​

Critical chain is described here as Goldratt set it out. The link between freed attention and high reliability is our argued position, set out in the article.

​

Hendrik Lourens, MBA, MSc, FAusIMM, COHSProf, has applied the Theory of Constraints in manufacturing, projects and mining.

NEXT STEP

​

Which project is keeping you awake?

​

Tell us about one project or shutdown and what it is up against. Hendrik will talk it through with you.

RELATED READING

​

On this site

​

One mine, two scoreboards

The same lesson in a mine, including the Development game for project teams.

​

Capacity to be safe

Why spare capacity matters for safe work.

​

Breaching the mining fatalities plateau

Hendrik’s peer-reviewed article on management attention, stability and safety.

​

Beyond Green Ticks

The Control Effectiveness Assessment, developed by Kelvin Genn at Art of Work.

​

Flow in job shops and supply chains

Two games and a plant turnaround that use the same rules.

​

​

The light rail case comes from Hendrik’s own work at Stratflow in 2018. Game results come from teaching models and are not forecasts for any operation.

  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
bottom of page